Sample Two Stanford Long Essay
-
Overlooking my reflection in the ebbing water, I lift the seaweed covering the glistening tide pool. Peering inside, my eyes catch a delicate movement. I reach down, close my hand, and fish out a vibrant amalgam of lush ulva, scarlet caulerpa, and sand full of fragmented shells. Sifting through this treasure in my cupped hands, I’m left with a cluster of minuscule hermit crabs. Antennae and legs slowly poking out of their shells, I note their distinct, cerulean bands, but before I know it, they’ve scuttled back into the water.
Putting my curiosity to use, I pursued research with the Z oyster lab. Sitting in muddy crates before dawn, I smiled at every oyster I uncovered in those endless hours. I found immense joy in these simple tasks, yet I was somehow unsatisfied with our inefficient methods and grew impatient not witnessing the tangible results.
There had to be a better way. Scouring the morass of alternative data collection techniques I deemed “still too inefficient”, I finally found it. Looking toward pictures of our fieldwork, I remembered using Google Lens to put a name on those elusive creatures I encountered in my childhood tidepool adventures. Maybe we could automate harvesting data using these photos rather than tediously hand-collecting it, saving so much time for our groundbreaking researchers.
Inspired by machine learning, the backbone of Google Lens, I proposed the idea to Dr. Z, who immediately became invested. Just like that, my simple idea matured into a sophisticated project that I was expected to execute single-handedly.
But scared that my decisions would be wrong, I pushed Dr. Z to decide the direction of my research. There was just one problem: nobody in the lab, including her, had experience with this technology. Her seemingly basic questions like, “What is the optimal split for the dataset?” or “Are you allowed to use photos you intend to analyze in the training set?” were usually met with my, “I don’t know.”
Seeing my model fail to identify what was so obvious to my eyes felt like empty hands after combing through a promising tidepool; I was utterly confused. Struggling was familiar, but not having someone to look to for answers wasn’t. In water polo, I never had to worry about thinking for myself and just had to follow the play. In cello, I never had to come up with my own interpretation of a piece, I just had to recreate my teacher’s. I missed having decisions made for me, but hearing my mentor tell her peers about this incredible project, I couldn’t bear giving up on my vision, if she could see it too.
I scoured the internet for every tutorial I could find, even resorting to ones that weren’t in English, and I rummaged through published research on machine learning used in diverse scientific fields like agriculture or neuroscience. After countless training iterations and augmentations to the image dataset, the model was finally strong enough. Not perfect, but strong, and for once, that was okay with me.
Standing in front of my poster at research conferences and fielding questions from a sea of brilliant ecologists, I know that behind me, is the work of an emerging marine ecologist with promising impact. I’ve always struggled to make my own decisions, leaning on others to tell me what to do, but my decision to actualize my vision is one I can truly call my own. Emerging from my shell of self-doubt, I’ve learned that by trusting myself and my curiosity, I can achieve so much more.
-
CCC: I think the last thought is a bit too forced. Can you just set the scene and say that most of the crab retreated into the shells and didn't even more, but there was one or a few more daring crabs who poked their legs out and scuttled back into the water. The ending is good
APPLICANT: The think to myself part?
CCC: yes that sentence. but i think all of these highlighted sentences could be repurposed to just explain that there are 2 types of crabs: shy vs confident. that's enough to intro the theme and set you up for the conclusion. the reason why i dont want you to say that crab is strangely confident is that you haven't introduced the topic of confidence yet so it sounds really strange. it's too forced. just describe now, and as the reader reads, they'll start to understand what you were doing.
APPLICANT: Like this?
CCC: yes precisely. but does this resonate with you? don't want to stray too far away from your vision - just want to help make it clearer to a 3P reader who's reading it for the first time
APPLICANT: Yes, I think this idea is rather good. I'm just wondering why I didn't think of this early for my other apps... -
Noticing my reflection in the ebbing water, I lift the seaweed covering the glistening tide pool. Peering inside, my eyes catch a delicate movement. I reach down, close my hand, and fish out a vibrant fistful of lush ulva, scarlet caulerpa, and sand full of fragmented shells. Sifting through this treasure in my cupped hands, I’m left with a cluster of minuscule hermit crabs. Antennae and legs slowly poking out of a few of the more daring ones, I note their distinct, cerulean bands as they quickly scuttle back into the water, while the rest of the shy crabs are still scared frozen.
-
CCC: do you actually talk like this? between this and "vibrant amalgam" in the first paragraph, i did wonder how much of this was chatgpt aided, and that's even with me already knowing you're a really strong writer.
APPLICANT: I had someone else take a look and they suggested the word "morass" I didn't use any AI. Amalgam was a word from my head and if needed I can change it to "fistful" if that sounds more natural
CCC: i know you didn't use AI, but it sounded like maybe you stuck a word into thesaurus.com and just took what came out. i just wanted to share my immediate reaction as context for you to consider (sorry im going for efficiency so not bothering sugar coating but not trying to be harsh), bc if it seems weird to me, it could very well have the same effect on someone else. the words are all accurate - just very formal
APPLICANT: I'll replace some of them. Amalgam -> Fistful, Morass -> Tangled mess
CCC: yea that's much better for morass (i wonder if whoever suggested it actually did you thesaurus.com it bc i really dont think anyone actually talks like that). however, amalgam is more normal and you could keep that if you want. it was just made to sound extra bookish bc it's paired w very scientific terms (lush ulva, scarlet caulerpa)
-
There had to be a better way. Scouring alternative data collection techniques I deemed “still too inefficient”, I finally found it. While referencing pictures of our fieldwork, I remembered using Google Lens, a machine learning application to put names to those elusive creatures I encountered in my childhood tidepool adventures. Maybe we could automate the way we harvested data using these photos rather than tediously hand-collecting it, saving so much time for our groundbreaking researchers.
-
CCC: this is a bit out of place without the context below that nobody else has tech chops. i would just cut this out and let your next paragraph explain that
APPLICANT: I just wanted to emphasize the expectations I felt right away. My mentor starting talking about how amazing it would be from the very beginning, even though I was unfamiliar with the technology.
CCC: yeah but you being unfamiliar with the technology is a separate idea from the expectation to execute single-handedly
-
Inspired, I proposed the idea of developing a machine learning model to Dr. Zacherl, who immediately became invested. Just like that, my simple idea matured into a sophisticated project. There was just one problem: nobody in the lab, my mentor included, had experience with this technology. I couldn’t even answer her seemingly basic questions like, “What is the optimal split for the dataset?” or “Can you use photos you intend to analyze in the training set?” Expectations were heavy on my shoulders and I was scared I’d make the wrong decisions.
-
CCC: this isn't meaningful enough to put in quotes. can you just say I didn't know the answers to her seemingly basic questions...
-
REMOVED
-
APPLICANT: Do you think this first sentence is too negative? One piece of advice my teacher gave me was to be more optimistic, and talk about how the frustration turned into grit and persistence.
CCC: I think you do that two paragraphs later. It's okay to present the problem you're faced with. This didn't strike me as too negative. The only comment I had on the next sentence was to make it more succinct and not dwell too much on the "negative." Aka just say that the expectations were heavy and you were scared you'd make wrong decisions (and delete the extra i felt helpless)
-
Seeing my model fail to identify what was so obvious to my eyes felt like empty hands after combing through a promising tidepool; I was utterly confused. Struggling was familiar, but not having someone to look to for answers wasn’t. In water polo, I never had to worry about thinking for myself and just had to follow the coach’s play. In cello, I never had to come up with my own interpretation of a piece, I just had to recreate my teacher’s. I missed having decisions made for me, but hearing my mentor tell her peers about this incredible project, I couldn’t bear giving up on my vision if she could see it too.
-
CCC: i love this - it's actually a great analogy of mlm: learning from iterations and application
-
I scoured the internet for every tutorial I could find, even resorting to ones that weren’t in English, and I rummaged through published research on machine learning used in diverse scientific fields like agriculture and neuroscience. After countless training iterations and augmentations to the image dataset, the model was finally strong enough. Not perfect, but strong, and for once, that was okay with me. Slowly but surely, I began to learn that science is defined by the pursuit for improvement, not perfection.
-
CCC: i still think it could easily be lost on someone that this is a poster that is literally behind you. you could just as easily say that I know that it is the work of an emerging marine ecologist..
CCC: don't like the shell analogies - too much. especially shell of experience and seeing your own shell
APPLICANT: Is there any way I could make it work? I kind of wanted to draw the parallel between myself and the hermit crabs, which I mention here in the end and in the beginning
CCC: okay say it again here what exactly is the parallel you want to draw? also you can totally keep the hermit crabs as a subject, but just don't overuse the shell analogy
APPLICANT: Ok in the intro, I want to give the reader some insight into my love for the ocean and hands on curiosity, while establishing how skittish / shy hermit crabs are. Here, I talking about my shell, I hope to draw that parallel that I felt like a hermit crab and in the last paragraph, I hope to continue that parallel by saying that if these hermit crabs (both literally and figuratively in the sense of people of like) just acknowledged how far they've come, they would feel more confident.
CCC: okay i get it now. can you move this to the next paragraph so it's combined with the hermit crab and makes the analogy more clear? flow would be something like you're reflecting with/talking to the hermit crab. and noting that you were able to emerge from your own shell stronger. and your point above about how they can do the same?
-
Now, when I present at scientific conferences and field questions from seas of brilliant naturalists, I know that my research is the work of an emerging marine ecologist with promising impact. I’ve previously struggled to make my own decisions, leaning on others to tell me what to do and faithfully carrying out what I was told, but here, my decision to actualize my vision is one I can truly call my own.
-
CCC: this sounds like it's meant to be a metaphor for something, but ends up being a dead end (aka it's just fluff)
APPLICANT: As I mentioned before, this was kind of ambitious. I wanted to show the reader how shy hermit crabs were, tying it in with the confidence at the end.
CCC: OH okay that is definitely a VERY subtle analogy. i see what you're saying. we can make it work but just pointing out that there is an inherent problem which is that they aren't just shy - they're trying to survive. it's not about being confident for them - if they don't follow these survival instincts they'll prob die.
APPLICANT: I suppose so. But I've definitely seen some hermits who are more confident than others. Some simply hide in their shells when I pick them up while others are proactive in running away, and waste no time staying still, scared to death.Would that be a more effective ending? Maybe mentioning my experience with a more "confident" hermit crab and drawing that parallel with myself? I could see how the current one is very confusing.
CCC: Yeah that makes more sense. If it's between the shy/helpless ones that just curl up and hide vs the more confident ones that take action and run away then it's a much stronger connection to your own growth
-
Back in the tide pools, I stumble across another “daring” hermit crab confident in its ability to emerge from its shell to escape danger when no other crab is willing to. Smiling, I can’t help but think that I’ve grown to become like this little crustacean. When I trust myself, I can achieve so much more. (650)
-
Noticing my reflection in the ebbing water, I lift the seaweed covering the glistening tide pool. Peering inside, my eyes catch a delicate movement. I reach down, close my hand, and fish out a vibrant fistful of lush ulva, scarlet caulerpa, and sand full of fragmented shells. Sifting through this treasure in my cupped hands, I’m left with a cluster of minuscule hermit crabs. Antennae and legs slowly poking out of a few of the more daring ones, I note their distinct, cerulean bands as they quickly scuttle back into the water, while the rest of the shy crabs are still scared frozen.
Putting my childhood curiosity for marine life to use, I pursued research with the Zacherl oyster lab. Sitting in muddy crates before dawn, I found immense joy digging in the mud for live oysters, never knowing what else I’d find. Yet I was unsatisfied with our inefficient data collection methods and grew impatient not witnessing tangible results.
There had to be a better way. Scouring alternative data collection techniques I deemed “still too inefficient”, I finally found it. While referencing pictures of our fieldwork, I remembered using Google Lens, a machine learning application to put names to those elusive creatures I encountered in my childhood tidepool adventures. Maybe we could automate the way we harvested data using these photos rather than tediously hand-collecting it, saving so much time for our groundbreaking researchers.
Inspired, I proposed the idea of developing a machine learning model to Dr. Zacherl, who immediately became invested. Just like that, my simple idea matured into a sophisticated project. There was just one problem: nobody in the lab, my mentor included, had experience with this technology. I couldn’t even answer her seemingly basic questions like, “What is the optimal split for the dataset?” or “Can you use photos you intend to analyze in the training set?” Expectations were heavy on my shoulders and I was scared I’d make the wrong decisions.
Seeing my model fail to identify what was so obvious to my eyes felt like empty hands after combing through a promising tidepool; I was utterly confused. Struggling was familiar, but not having someone to look to for answers wasn’t. In water polo, I never had to worry about thinking for myself and just had to follow the coach’s play. In cello, I never had to come up with my own interpretation of a piece, I just had to recreate my teacher’s. I missed having decisions made for me, but hearing my mentor tell her peers about this incredible project, I couldn’t bear giving up on my vision if she could see it too.
I scoured the internet for every tutorial I could find, even resorting to ones that weren’t in English, and I rummaged through published research on machine learning used in diverse scientific fields like agriculture and neuroscience. After countless training iterations and augmentations to the image dataset, the model was finally strong enough. Not perfect, but strong, and for once, that was okay with me. Slowly but surely, I began to learn that science is defined by the pursuit for improvement, not perfection.
Now, when I present at scientific conferences and field questions from seas of brilliant naturalists, I know that my research is the work of an emerging marine ecologist with promising impact. I’ve previously struggled to make my own decisions, leaning on others to tell me what to do and faithfully carrying out what I was told, but here, my decision to actualize my vision is one I can truly call my own.
Back in the tide pools, I stumble across another “daring” hermit crab confident in its ability to emerge from its shell to escape danger when no other crab is willing to. Smiling, I can’t help but think that I’ve grown to become like this little crustacean. When I trust myself, I can achieve so much more.
Personal Statement (650 word limit)